Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Gutters & Eavestroughs
Barrie ON L4N 4G2
Write a Review
Write a Review


HomeStars
Gutters & Eavestroughs
Reynolds Brothers Exteriors
Star Score
Learn more about how StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company's review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency.

99%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Indicates how well a pro reacts to reviews and review-related interactions with Homeowners.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)
Verified by HomeStars

Reviews for Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Average customer rating:
9.9 10 (475 reviews)

Sort by

Karla
Karla
3 reviews Aurora, ON
10/10

Gutter Replacement

Excellent communication from start to finish. Appointment times were spot on, and they offered suggestions on how to complete the project. The installation crew arrived on time and completed the job in one day. Price quoted was very competitive. Did wait approximately six weeks to be scheduled which was explained at the time of booking. Will definitely be using RB for future projects.

Approximate cost of services:
$2,900.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Hi Karla,
Thank you for your kind review! We're glad to hear you appreciated our communication, punctuality, and competitive pricing. While the wait time can vary depending on the season, we’re grateful for your understanding. We look forward to working with you on future projects!
Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Sara in Toronto
Sara in Toronto
1 review Shelburne, ON
10/10

5 Stars – Outstanding Experience!

We recently had Reynolds Brothers Exteriors transform the siding on our home, and we are absolutely thrilled with the results! From start to finish, their customer service was impeccabletruly 5-star. The teams dedication to excellence and their willingness to go the extra mile left us beyond impressed.

A heartfelt shout-out to the incredible siding crewAustin, Dave, and Tannerand the aluminum crewJessie, Ryan, Conner, and Elliott. Their attention to detail and quality craftsmanship were unmatched. Not only were they skilled, but they were also incredibly friendly, communicative, and always focused on ensuring we were satisfied at every stage of the project.

One standout moment that blew us away was when they noticed our roof was missing a drip edge and went ahead and installed one at no additional cost. This thoughtful action ensures that rainwater flows seamlessly into the eavestroughs rather than following the house. This level of care and attention to detail is a prime example of how they consistently go above and beyond.

An extra shout-out to Austinhe was incredibly knowledgeable, approachable, and made it his mission to ensure every detail met our expectations. His kindness and dedication didnt just meet our standardsthey exceeded them by miles.

The final product is stunning, and we couldnt be more satisfied with the transformation of our home. Reynolds Brothers Exteriors has earned our highest recommendation for anyone seeking not just excellent service, but an experience that leaves you truly delighted. Thank you for going above and beyondyouve exceeded every expectation we had!

Approximate cost of services:
$27,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Hi Sara, Thank you so much for your incredibly detailed and thoughtful review! We’re thrilled to hear how satisfied you are with your siding transformation and our team’s work. It means the world to us that Austin, Dave, Tanner, Jessie, Ryan, Conner, and Elliott made such a positive impression and delivered the level of care and craftsmanship we strive for.

We’re especially glad the drip edge installation stood out—it's those small details that can make a big difference, and it’s wonderful to hear it was appreciated. Your kind words and high recommendation truly motivate us to continue exceeding expectations.

Thank you again for choosing Reynolds Brothers Exteriors—it was a pleasure working with you on this project!

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Waubaushene, ON
10/10

Facia, soffit, eavesdrop, downspout

Dylan and his team, Cayden and Phil, have worked like a well oiled machine from start to finish. They were very kind and respectful whenever asked a question and gave very informative answers. They also made some great suggestions that were put into place and made total sense. The initial estimate was well explained with competitive pricing when compared to other companies including clarifications on the work that was to be completed. It has been a very positive experience and would wholeheartedly recommend Reynold Brothers Exteriors. Great job guys!! Laura and Grant

Approximate cost of services:
$17,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Hi Laura and Grant,

Thank you so much for this thoughtful review! We’re thrilled to hear that Dylan, Cayden, and Phil delivered a positive experience for you from start to finish. It’s wonderful that their suggestions made a difference and that the entire process, from the estimate through completion, was clear and competitive.

Your recommendation means a lot to us, and I’ll be sure to pass along your kind words to the team—they’ll appreciate it. Thank you again for choosing Reynolds Brothers Exteriors!
Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Adam
Adam
1 review Barrie, ON
10/10

Great work

The team did a great job fixing up the eavestroughs before winter. Onsite team was quick and efficient and the office team was friendly and helpful. Great service all around.

Approximate cost of services:
$4,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you for your kind words! We’re so glad to hear that both our onsite and office teams provided the friendly, efficient service you were looking for. It’s great knowing your eavestroughs are set for winter. Thanks again for choosing Reynolds Brothers Exteriors!

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Private User
Private User
1 review , ON
10/10

Eaves, facia and soffitt

From the quote to the final installation, and everything in between Reynolds is and was amazing!

Every person I spoke to on the phone was as so professional and truly wanted to make this purchase a great experience. They always have time for you!

But what really highlighted Reynolds was the crew that installed the products- Mike and his crew were very thoughtful in every way, showed up at a consistent time, clean and open to ideas and questions. Mike really looks after his crew and I learned a lot about leadership and teamwork from Mike and his team!!

Thank you for everything!! And the job is done to perfection!!!

Approximate cost of services:
$10,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re thrilled to hear that from the quote to the final installation, every step exceeded your expectations. Our team strives to ensure each client feels heard and valued, and it's wonderful to know that Mike and his crew made such a positive impact. Their dedication and attention to detail reflect the teamwork and care we aim for on every project. Thank you again for choosing Reynolds—we’re here whenever you need us!

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Newmarket, ON
10/10

Vinyl Siding Replacement

We recently had the old vinyl siding on the entire house replaced. For me, 4 stars is what I provide only when work is done as expected. 5 stars is reserved for work done above and beyond expected. In this case, 5 stars for the whole company, from first contact to job completion, to payment(s).

Jesse was the person who estimated the job. I wasn't available at the time he checked out the house, but he arrived, did his work and left the location in the condition he found it. After getting the quote, I asked for a modification to the job and he was very agreeable and said that the extra cost of doing so was minimal.

Before the work started, I wanted to see some samples. Angel in the office arranged for one of their installers, who lived nearby, to bring a sample book. He let us keep the samples which we returned when the work started. We were then able to make a comparison of the colours and qualities and made our decision.

Shannon was our contact for making arrangements for payment. Only 30% was required as a deposit. They accept e-transfer, and with our transfer limit we had to make 3 transactions. No problem.

Obviously, the work on the house is the most important. All work was done in a professional manner. Josh and his team (Ian and Ray) did the work with the most care, and extremely thoroughly. Removal and haul away of the old siding, removal of two awnings, haul away of one which we never used and reinstallation of the other which is used every day, prep for install, install of underlayment, and install of new siding. They boxed in, with metal flashing, all the pipes that come through the wall, metal flashing everywhere, all the expected stuff, some unexpected stuff and then caulking. Josh provided information regarding what they will be doing, what they did every day and what had been done in the past. The original siding on the gables on our home (built in the mid '70s) was backed with drywall, which over the past 50 years had become soggy, mouldy and could not be used as backing anymore. Josh pointed this out and told us what needed to be done to correct it. They replaced it with good solid plywood, which will remain good for the rest of the life of the house, without disturbing any of the attic insulation. The house looks fantastic now, and with all the underlayment, fully taped to prevent wind infiltration, we expect to be a bit warmer in the house this winter.

Only when the work was completed did we get the invoice for the balance of the job. This is fantastic, since there were no worries about paying the whole amount up front and wondering if the job would be completed to our satisfaction. Finally, I talked with Shawn in the office regarding payment, and he had no problem with 9 e-transfers.

Fantastic company all around.

Approximate cost of services:
$24,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a detailed and thoughtful review! We’re thrilled to hear that your experience with our team, from start to finish, exceeded your expectations. Jesse, Angel, Shannon, Josh, Ian, Ray, and the entire crew work hard to ensure a smooth process and high-quality results, and it’s wonderful to know that their efforts made a positive impact.

It’s feedback like yours that motivates us to continue going above and beyond for our customers. We hope the improvements keep your home comfortable and looking great for years to come!

Thanks again for trusting us with your project, and please don’t hesitate to reach out if you need anything in the future.

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Private User
Private User
1 review Barrie, ON
10/10

Siding Replacement

Very friendly and knowledgeable customer services that explained the whole process of the renovation. Their team that replaced the siding where very knowledgeable on the product they were working with and were seasoned workers with that company.

It was a pleasure to talk to them they were very friendly, approachable and their ability to problem solving was excellent.

The construction team were relax and appeared not to be rush to complete the task and the attention to detail with the craftmanship was apparent.

I would recommend this company who would require their siding replaced.

Approximate cost of services:
$20,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We're glad to hear that our team made the renovation process smooth and enjoyable for you. It’s wonderful to know that their expertise, problem-solving skills, and attention to detail stood out. We appreciate your recommendation and please let us know if you need anything in the future!

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Doug
Doug
1 review Barrie, ON
10/10

From Drab to Stunning

We recently had the incredible experience of working with Reynolds Brothers Exteriors, and they have completely transformed the exterior of our home. What was once a dull, grey, and uninspired façade is now a stunning showpiece featuring gorgeous white Gentek board and batten siding, perfectly accented with sleek black trim.

A huge shout-out to Ian Russell, who led the entire project with precision and care. Ian's attention to detail and dedication to quality was evident in every step of the process. His teamTristan and Aldiswere hardworking, professional, and meticulous in their work, ensuring the installation was flawless. We couldn't have asked for a better crew to bring our vision to life.

We also want to extend a big thanks to the "trough" team, Cayden and Phil, led by Dylan. Their craftsmanship was top-notch, and they did an outstanding job installing the new trough system, which not only looks great but functions perfectly. Its clear they take pride in their work, and the results speak for themselves.

Finally I want to recognize Jessie, whose leadership in selling the project made everything possible. Jessies clear communication, guidance, and expertise ensured we felt confident and excited about the transformation from day one.

Overall, the entire Reynolds Brothers team worked together seamlessly, delivering exceptional results. Our home is now the envy of the neighborhood, and we couldnt be happier. If youre looking for a talented, reliable, and passionate team to handle your home transformation, we wholeheartedly recommend Reynolds Brothers. Thank you again for making our home beautiful!

Doug and Emily

Approximate cost of services:
$75,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Hi Doug and Emily,

Wow, what an incredible review! Thank you so much for sharing your experience. We’re thrilled to hear how happy you are with the transformation of your home—it sounds like quite the stunning makeover!

Ian, Tristan, Aldis, Cayden, Phil, Dylan, and Jessie will be so pleased to hear your kind words about their work and dedication. We take great pride in our team’s craftsmanship, and it’s always rewarding to know our customers are delighted with the results.

We’re honored to have been part of your home’s transformation, and if there’s ever anything else we can do for you, don’t hesitate to reach out.

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Private User
Private User
1 review Midland, ON
10/10

Eaves and filters

WONDERFUL CREW! WORK WAS COMPLETED QUICKLY, LEAVING NO MESS FOR US TO BE CONCERNED ABOUT. I ORIGINALLY WANTED A DOWNPIPE TO FEED DIRECTLY INTO MY FLOWER BED, BUT I WAS STRONGLY ADVISED NOT TO DO THAT, TO AVOID DAMAGING THE WALLS OF THE BED. GREAT WORKMANSHIP, GREAT CREW, AND NO MESS! THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH. I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS COMPANY.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you so much for your fantastic review! We're happy to hear that you had a positive experience with our crew and that our recommendation helped protect your flower bed. It's great to know you appreciated the workmanship and cleanliness. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we’re always here if you need anything in the future. Thanks again!

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Caroline
Caroline
1 review Barrie, ON
10/10

Eavestrough

Reynolds Bros were so great to deal with. They showed up on time and were very friendly. They made sure everything was cleaned up when they finished. Im so happy with their service!! I would definitely use them again!!

Approximate cost of services:
$3,100.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Hi Caroline, Thank you so much for your kind review! We're thrilled to hear that you were happy with our service. Punctuality and cleanliness are always priorities for us, so we're glad that stood out to you.

Best regards, Shawn.
Co-Owner Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Reynolds Brothers Exteriors

Reynolds Brothers Exteriors – Gutters like no other! Offering eavestroughs/siding/downpipes, soffit/fascia, leaf gutter guard, and windows/doors.

Reynolds Brothers is a family-run business whose main focus is our commitment to honesty, quality, and customer service. Eavestroughs & Exteriors are often the last thing people think about but are your home's first line of defense against nature's elements. Our first-class workmanship combined with the most unique and durable options will protect your home for decades to come. Take a look, you’ll be impressed! We offer 4 different styles of eavestrough which really stands out from other companies.

#1 in Customer Service - Our family-run operation is a Homestars Best of 2017 Award Winner and takes pride in our customer service. You can take comfort in knowing that only our professionally trained staff will visit your home to ensure that you get the quality that you deserve. You can be sure that your experience with Reynolds Bros. will be a positive one. From your first contact, through to work completion and inspection, we are very careful to treat both our clients and their beautiful homes with utmost care and respect. We treat you like Family!

Check out our recent Homestars featured article with Ryan from Reynolds Brothers.

http://blog.homestars.com/archives/top-10-gutter-and-eavestrough-questions/
https://www.readersdigest.ca/home-garden/home-improvement/winter-proof-your-house/

CATEGORIES
Gutters & Eavestroughs and Siding
PRODUCTS
Eavestroughs/Siding Soffit/Fascia Leafguard/Windows/Doors
SERVICES
Eavestrough Replacement/ Siding Installation/ Eavestrough Repair/ Leafguard-Gutter Guard/ Eavestrough Cleaning/ Roofing Services/ Downpipes/ De-icing Cables/ Colour Recommendations
BRANDS
Kaycan Preferred Supplier/ Elite Installer Alu Rex Gutter Guards Maibec Gentek Royal Building
STYLES
We offer Unique Styles of Eavestroughs! We offer numerous colour choices for your home.
SPECIALITIES
Best of the Best Homestars Winner 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 & 2022 and #1 in customer service!
WEBSITE
http://www.reynoldsbros.ca
YEAR ESTABLISHED
12
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
35
PAYMENT METHOD
E-transfer, Check, Credit Card and Cash
LICENSES
Yes
MEMBERSHIPS
Coverved by WSIB
LIABILITY INSURANCE
Yes
DIPLOMAS
Vinyl Siding Institute Accredited
WORKERS COMPENSATION
Yes
WRITTEN CONTRACT
Yes
WARRANTY TERMS
5 years Installation / 20 years Materials
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.