We recently had a walkway, driveway and landscaping done. Of all the work done, the driveway is the one that I have the most concerns about. They were recommended by Harper's Garden Center (who we were happy with). They were terrible at responding to phone calls, and timing. When the driveway finally went in, we weren't home during the work, so I can't verify how thick the asphalt was laid. Also, when I got home afterwards, there was no barrier across the driveway to stop cars driving on it, and no sheet about what to do (I read on the internet not to drive on it for 3 days). The work they did was good - the lines were very clean, and they meshed well with the surrounding landscape. However, I am concerned how it will age. If the driveway looks good in 3 years, I would easily rate them an 8.
(revisiting this review) I'm staying with the 5 star review. It was only a year after installation, we had some cracks near the edge (12 inches from the edge) with some weeds growing through. We called them about it, but never heard back.